Skip to main content
site map
contact
email usour twitterour facebook page pintrest youtube
Politics

Of Course We're Not a Democracy

by Senator Mike Lee

During the recent vice presidential debate, I pointed out on Twitter that our form of government in the United States is not a democracy, but a republic. The confused and vehement media criticism that ensued persuaded me that this point might be better served in an essay rather than a 140-character Tweet.

Insofar as “democracy” means “a political system in which government derives its powers from the consent of the governed,” then of course that accurately describes our system. But the word conjures far more than that. It is often used to describe rule by majority, the view that it is the prerogative of government to reflexively carry out the will of the majority of its citizens.

Our system of government is best described as a constitutional republic. Power is not found in mere majorities, but in carefully balanced power. Under our Constitution, passing a bill in the House of Representatives—the body most reflective of current majority views—isn’t enough for it to become law. Legislation must also be passed by the Senate—where each state is represented equally (regardless of population), where members have longer terms, and where (under current rules) a super-majority vote is typically required to bring debate to a close. Thomas Jefferson described the Senate as the “saucer” that cools hot passions more prevalent in the House. It’s where consensus is forged, as senators reach compromise across regional, cultural, and partisan lines.

Once passed by both houses of Congress, a bill still doesn’t become a law until it’s signed (or acquiesced to) by the president—who of course is elected not by popular national vote, but by the electoral college of the states.

And then, at last, the Supreme Court—a body consisting not of elected officials, but rather individuals appointed to lifetime terms—has the power to strike down laws that violate the Constitution. What could be more undemocratic?

As I said in a follow-up Tweet, democracy itself is not the goal. The goal is freedom, prosperity, and human flourishing. Democratic principles have proven essential to those goals, but only as part of a system of checks and balances among the executive, legislative, and judicial branches of the federal government, as well as between the federal government and the states.

Rest assured, every single critic who attacked me for correctly crediting America’s political success as a republic, not a democracy, supports counter-democratic checks and balances on majorities he disagrees with. My critics support Supreme Court decisions that overturned democratically enacted laws. They support Democratic filibusters of conservative legislation to, for instance, repeal Obamacare or allow for school choice or build a border wall to stop illegal immigration.

Advocates of “democracy” have convinced themselves the obstacle to progress in Washington is all these counter-democratic parts of our system. In truth, Congress’s failure to pass sweeping progressive—or conservative—legislation in recent decades is a signal that neither party has won the necessary support from the American people to pass it. That does not indicate a flaw in the system, but flaws in the two parties’ agendas. This is a feature, not a bug.

In the absence of national consensus, there isn’t supposed to be federal law. That’s what the states are for—to provide smaller, more homogeneous polities to reflect our broad national diversity. There is no reason New Yorkers and South Carolinians and Hawaiians have to have the exact same health care or education or welfare or tax policies. If diversity is a strength—and nearly all Americans agree that it is—our diversity has to be allowed to flex its muscles.

Right now, one political party is threatening to undermine one of the republican checks included in the Constitution—the Supreme Court—with a plan to pack the Court with progressive judges. But you can’t pack the Court without inevitably threatening things like religious freedom and freedom of speech—things that are unpopular but are protected by the Constitution precisely because they are unpopular. In that sense, our Constitution is fundamentally undemocratic.

Only in a constitutional republic are Americans’ individual rights and cultural diversity given their proper position atop our political order, over and above even majority will. Even above the tweets of social media outrage mobs. Thank goodness.

Mike Lee is the senior United States senator from Utah.

If you are a candidate in the upcoming Bedford County primary or general election and would like to tell your story, please send us an email and we will schedule an interview and get your message out.  This is a FREE service brought to you by Shelbyville NOW.   Send your email to admin@shelbyvillenow.com

County Mayor- Current



Chad Graham    

 

 

Trustee-  Current


Tonya Davis 



Sheriff- Current



Austin Swing         


Register of Deeds- Current



Johnny Reed                   

 


Circuit Court Clerk- Current


Michelle Murray  


County Clerk -  Current


Donna Thomas 


County School Board- Current


District #1-  David Brown
District #2 -  Brian Crews  
District #3 -  Dan Reed 
District #4 -  Diane Neeley 
District #5 -  Michael Cook
District #6 -  Andrea Anderson
District #7 -  Nicole Cashion
District #8 -  John Boutwell
District #9 -  Glen Forsee   

County Commissioners   (Current)
District Maps :  CLICK HERE


     District

Address

Town

Zip Code

                Phone

DISTRICT 1

 

 

 

 

 

Don Gallagher

PO Box 128,
303 Vine St.

Wartrace

37183

931-389-6650
931-224-1431

1965gallagher@gmail.com

Bobby Fox

101 Parker Circle

Shelbyville

37160

931-684-2135  

DISTRICT 2

 

 

 

 

 

Greg Vick

245 Edd Joyce Rd.

Bell Buckle

37020

615-210-7246

greg.vick@bedfordcountytn.gov

Tony Smith

295 Pepper Hill Rd.

Bell Buckle

37020

931-437-2287
931-607-6140

trs3847@yahoo.com

DISTRICT 3

 

 

 

 

 

Janice Brothers

119 Wildwood Dr.

Unionville

37180

 

jbrothers1@united.net

Jason Sanders

 215 Staley Rd 

Unionville

37180

931-224-4934 

sandersplumbing2016@gmail.com

DISTRICT 4

 

 

 

 

 

Anita Epperson

115 Coleman Harvey Ln.

Shelbyville

37160

931-580-8907

anita.epperson4@bedfordcountytn.gov

Brian Farris

301 Billy Darnell Ln.

Shelbyville

37160

931-273-3016

brian.farris@bedfordcountytn.gov

DISTRICT 5

 

 

 

 

 

Jeff Sweeney

241 Cortner Mill Rd

Normandy

37360

615-892-0599

jeff.sweeney@bedfordcountytn.gov

Linda Yockey

560 Moore Rd.

Shelbyville

37160

931-857-3171
931-607-5875

lindayockey@gmail.com

DISTRICT 6

 

 

 

 

 

Bill Anderson

1934 Wartrace Pk.

Shelbyville

37160

931-607-8485

mbpencil@gmail.com

Adam Thomas

808 South Brittain St.

Shelbyville

37160

615-310-6011

Adamthomas1001@gmail.com

DISTRICT 7

 

 

 

 

 

Julie Wells Sanders

110 Blue Ribbon Pkwy

Shelbyville

37160

931-492-4391
931-580-5854

juliesandersdistrict7@gmail.com

Sylvia Pinson

219 Warren Circle

Shelbyville

37160

931-580-0379

sylvia.pinson@bedfordcountytn.gov

DISTRICT 8

 

 

 

 

 

John Brown

235 E. Cedar St.

Shelbyville

37160

931-684-4296
931-703-9502

john.brown@bedfordcountytn.gov

Ed Castleman

123 Scotland Heights

Shelbyville

37160

931-684-5329

Email

DISTRICT 9

 

 

 

 

 

Mark Thomas

112 Stonegate Circle

Shelbyville

37160

931-684-1105

mark.thomas@bedfordcountytn.gov

P.T. "Biff" Farrar

104 Rosewood Dr.

Shelbyville

37160

931-684-2987

farrarb1949@charter.net

Bell Buckle Municipal


Mayor

Ronnie W. Lokey 


Alderman  

Zachary Akers       
James Anderson